If you have never been a landlord before...then one good test is to ask yourself:
Am I the type who might react in this manner: "look what they did to my sink!???"
If that reaction sounds anything like you, then just stop now because you should not be a landlord.
If you are leaning toward a more stable, manageable leasing option, in the end an annual tenant probably costs you less time, money, and aggravation because you only have one party to deal with, and only one party moving in and out for the year, and they stay.
Naturally, frequent tenant turn-over results in more damage to the home (and more money, time, and aggravation) because you expose your property to more and different people. Every time someone new moves in, moves out, has guests, has pets or uses an appliance... something in the house takes a hit.
Keep in mind many communities have restrictions, but regardless, the likelihood of covering costs or making a profit with a seasonal rental are extremely low... unless one of the following is true:
Seasonal tenants come for 2-6 month stints (usually between November and April), and you can believe that most treat your place no different than a rental car.
More often than not, keeping it vacant just makes more sense financially and also from the standpoint of aggravation.
Remember that if your home is a member of an HOA or COA there may be unfavorable restrictions on your rental plans. If you ignore those rules and get caught you can be liable for fines, and if the tenant had to vacate you could be sued. An existing violation typically blocks a sale from completing should you decide to sell.
Following are typical restrictions:
DEFINITION: Be aware of what is considered "Transient Public Lodgeing Establishment" - Any unit, group of units, dwelling, building, or group of buildings within a single complex of buildings which is rented to guests more than three times in a calendar year for periods of less than 30 days or 1 calendar month, whichever is less, or which is advertised or held out to the public as a place regularly rented to guests.(sip FL state Gov)
If it looks like you are running a hotel without a hospitality license and its unknown to or against the rules of your association, you may face fines and charges from your building, community, municipality or the state. Don't be surprised if the neighbors report apparent illicit activity, even if that's NOT what's going on.
If in fact you are legitimately renting multiple times a year you will be liable for "Transient Accomodation" which carries a 6% sales tax. Dont forget to plan for that because the state will come looking for their money.
Owners with only own one solitary single family residence that was not intentionally bought to lease out at a profit, will typically find that renting it out is a costly decision. That's because with few exceptions, profit is only achieved when purchased for profit to begin with: at a specific price to get a specific return.
So unless you intentionally bought the place at a price that by calculations was able to provide a profit, you are not likely to generate one.
Holding on to a losing investment is no different than paying for an employee who does not work.If your rental is ACTUALLY generating a profit, worth the risk, time, and aggravation... then you have a great investment!
Remember: a stock, bond, or insurance instrument could possibly earn the same money but does not call you at 8pm Saturday evening to complain, and has no walls to make holes in, no tiles to crack, no appliances to break... and no one can sue you for getting hurt while inside one.
If so, it is important to complete an honest calculation to determine if it will ACTUALLY generate enough income to be worth the risk, time, and aggravation. Start by calculating:
+ Income – Cost = Net Income
Net Income > (Risk + Time + Aggravation) ?
In other countries, landlords may pass some of these costs onto the tenant separately. Here in the US, however, it's simply part of the rent you are charging the tenant. Don’t go trying to increase the rent to cover these costs to the point that you are no longer competitive, because you will find that tenants will go elsewhere to rent.
It’s better to have your place empty and losing money than to have let a dead-beat tenant into your property.
A bad tenant brings with it as much turmoil as identity theft, takes months and thousands of dollars of loss and cost to resolve... and you will be the proud sponsor of a local attorney's child's college fund. The following are what you should be prepared to require of any prospective tenant in order to evaluate them and have them be accepted by your association (if your home is part of an association):
...go ahead and use our tenant application to send prospects a set of background questions that you can use to determine which one is the best candidate.
We are in a world steeped in bureaucracy where it's so easy for a tenant to file a complaint leading to endless hours in a courtroom with expensive attorneys
Here is a punchlist of what to watch out for